You are not logged in.

#1 2020-06-26 12:57:20

mpele
Member
Registered: 2012-02-25
Posts: 250

Ways which have a tag addr:*=... but are not closed ways.

Да ли неко разуме каква се грешка пријављује за све улице у Калуђерици?

https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=a … closed_way

Ways which have a tag addr:*=... but are not closed ways.

Offline

#2 2020-07-01 15:09:59

Duja
Member
Registered: 2019-03-13
Posts: 49

Re: Ways which have a tag addr:*=... but are not closed ways.

Hoće da kaže da addr:* tagove ne treba stavljati na ulice, nego samo na građevine predstavljene poligonima (tj. closed ways) ili tačkama. Zaista ne razumem zašto je neko sve ulice tagovao sa addr:suburb=Калуђерица.

Koliko znam, preporuka je da se addr: koristi u najmanjoj mogućoj meri kako bi se smanjila redundancija (npr. za kućni broj je dovoljno staviti addr:number i addr:street, a sve ostale parametre adrese treba da izvede renderer/Nominatim na osnovu geolokacije).

Neko je slično uradio i u Novom Sadu, svaka božja ulica je dobila poštanski broj, i to ne 21000 nego onaj od lokalne pošte (21137 i sl.). Nisam siguran ni da je to korektno, doduše nisam nikad shvatio kako funkcioniše to adresiranje ni u stvarnom životu.

Offline

#3 2020-07-01 15:58:56

TXBG
Member
Registered: 2019-11-11
Posts: 7

Re: Ways which have a tag addr:*=... but are not closed ways.

As usual when setting an address there should be an addr:street=* matching the name=* of the respective street. Then addr:suburb=* with the same value must be added on both the address to set up and the street.
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:addr:suburb
Možda ja nisam nešto dobro razumeo?

Offline

#4 2020-07-01 16:15:15

TXBG
Member
Registered: 2019-11-11
Posts: 7

Re: Ways which have a tag addr:*=... but are not closed ways.

Duja wrote:

Zaista ne razumem zašto je neko sve ulice tagovao sa addr:suburb=Калуђерица.

Zato što Magic Earth iz nekog razloga ignoriše administrativne granice u Beogradu i prilikom pretrage ponekad izlista i po 5-6 ulica i za sve njih kaže Beograd i kako da znaš gde je koja. Koliko sam primetio, jedino za adrese u Surčinu i Staroj Bežaniji pravi razliku. Ovo je pokušaj u tom smeru i nadam se da nije pucanj u prazno. Za potvrdu čekam update mape. Ako ne bude bilo rezultata i ako je ovo pogrešno, lako je vratiti u pređašnje stanje.

Offline

#5 2020-07-02 08:53:50

Duja
Member
Registered: 2019-03-13
Posts: 49

Re: Ways which have a tag addr:*=... but are not closed ways.

Ne bih nužno rekao da je "pogrešno", samo je redundantno, a redundancija može uzrokovati greške drugog tipa kasnije u lancu.

To je primer tagovanja za renderer, ovaj put za Magic Earth (za koji prvi put čujem, iskreno).

The basic good practice principle is that you avoid using incorrect tags, or otherwise skewing the data you enter, to make things show up in a specific way on the map rendering.

The phrase usually refers to renderers, but it also applies for routing and geocoding and other uses of the data. Further examples could be conceived for these as well.

Addresses strana savetuje da se adrese stavljaju samo na zgrade:

Addresses can be tagged with addr:housenumber=* and the other addr:* keys. Tags can be added to :

*   isolated nodes inside building=* polygons
*  building=* polygons
*  nodes that are parts of building polygons ( = entrance=*s) or on the access to a property (e.g. on barrier=gate or barrier=entrance), used in places where addresses are assigned to entrances and accesses rather than to buildings)
*  on polygons representing the perimeter of the site (if addresses are assigned to buildings this approach should be avoided)

Offline

#6 2020-07-28 23:33:20

TXBG
Member
Registered: 2019-11-11
Posts: 7

Re: Ways which have a tag addr:*=... but are not closed ways.

Obrisao sam sve addr:street tagove sa ulica pošto nije bilo očekivanih rezultata.

Offline

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB