I donāt they should in this case. Since its only a few people who originally did, along with continue to do, the reversals in the first place and I had more support for the pages being deleted then not. Which you continue to ignore and Iām sick of repeating myself about.
I actually took a six month ābreakā where I consulted other people about this, who agreed with me, and waited to see if original pages were deleted before I requested more pages be deleted. I even reverted a few of my own deletion requests in the mean time that I thought could have been thought out more or had more discussion. Everyone learns as they go. Even me. I never said there was zero room for improvement on my part or that 100% of my edits were fantastic. Just that the ratio of hate to wrong was way off and that we should figure out some rules so both can be mitigated in the future. Iām not sure why thatās such an issue.
Again, I donāt think the wiki should be ran based on opinions of the few loudest voices in the room. Especially when they are the clear minority. Simply because has someone āhas an issue with somethingā doesnāt really mean anything either. It things should be based on more then outrage. Every opinion should be heard and considered. That goes for everything here, not just in my case. You clearly disagree with that.
No. Iām cool. I rather trust that the admins made the right decision by deleting the pages. Last time I checked they know perfectly well what they are doing. Sometimes better then we do.
Its predictable you would ignore the fact that 99% of the pages I requested be deleted where as evidence that I was in the right though on most of them though. āIgnore the evidence and resort to personal attacks instead (see below)ā is a pretty bad tactic in general.
Iām not sure how its the wrong forum to point out that this might not be such a big controversy after all, when your the one that has repeatedly brought it up as a reason for things here, but whatever. I havenāt seen any discussions about this on the mailing lists either. Maybe you could provide a link to the discussions going there and also tell the people there it would be helpful if they joined this discussion so its not spread out everywhere.
Or its a personal thing (or maybe just that the people suffer from elitism). I donāt know why thatās so hard to imagine. You think people on here arenāt prone to personal grudges or any form of bias? Right. Verdy_P totally was. Its pretty easy to look through his talk page and see it. Iāve into to many intellectual disputes with both Polarbear, Mateusz Konieczny, and Nakenar in other places besides the wiki. They generally single certain people and act the same way they did here. Iāve even gotten private messages from other people saying they do the same thing to them. So donāt treat me like Iām making baseless statements with nothing to back it up.
As Iāve said I donāt care about complaints as a metric for anything. Following rules and guidelines are more important. Iāve said throughout this that Iām perfectly willing to talk to an admin or someone from the DWG to. The couple of times they have been involved they sided with me anyway. So I donāt really care.
Iām not sure whatās self-righteous about requested pages be deleted, pointing out that more people were fine with it then not (including admins), that there should be a discussion about so it doesnāt happen again in the future (which everyone benefits from), or me saying that if the people who raised concerned originally really cared they would be participating in the discussion. None of those things are self-righteous. If anything they are the exact opposite.
I could say though that its pretty self-righteous boss someone around on their talk page about something but not help them come up with a solution to the problem. I could also say the same thing about someone who says that if another person doesnāt like how the search on the wiki works, they should just use another search engine (which you did). Iām not going to stoop that level though because name calling is pointless, doesnāt resolve anything, and just makes the person doing it look needlessly petty. Which I rather avoid. Thereās enough pettiness around here already.
Btw, I wasnāt including you in the comment about fake outrage. It was in reference to the people who have a constant problem on my talk page over the last couple of years but donāt participate here. I have respect for the fact that your taking the time to participate in the forum. I donāt have respect for you calling me self-righteous or you putting this all on me though.