Here I’m trying to summarize the most hindering drawbacks of Potlatch as I’ve experienced while using it. Though I scanned the forum for “Potlatch”, I’m not sure, whether any item already has been discussed except #1. Hopefully my feedback will lead to an improvement of Pl.
**1. Erroneous import of gpx tracks
**
While tracking on bicycle I only switch on and off tracking. Thus I can track without stopping cycling. The result, when reading in the tracks to Mapsource are single Tracks named ACTIVE LOG – ACTIVE LOG 01 …. ACTIVE LOG nn, each of which representing a cycle between ON and OFF.
In Mapsource the tracks are displayed correctly. When writing the gpx, Mapsource creates adequate tracks in the gpx.
Reading in the gpx into Potlatch, the subsequent tracks are connected to each other.
This looks like this.
In the German OSM forum we discussed this problem comprehensively
here.
There I found out, that this interconnection is omitted, if the tag of the last track-point of every track is being removed. The same gpx as above then looks as follows.
Attention: this method causes Potlatch to remove the track point with missing tag. Also, after logout and new login, the tracks again are interconnected. We discussed, to save the tracks singularly each in an own gpx file and enter them zipped in Potlatch. This method proved not to prevent the problem.
Request: Independent tracks must be treated as independent tracks and never be interconnected.
2. Translating tracks automatically to ways
Automatic translated tracks first are displayed in red colour. I didnÂ’t manage to find out, what operation is necessary that potlatch recognizes those ways as real and worth, being saved.
- I connect those ways to other existing ways – the colour stays red.
- I define those ways as highways – the colour remains red.
This all ends up, that suddenly, the red coloured ways are disappeared, while my connections attached to those ways are hanging in the air.
Request: a defined operation to get the red coloured ways to real ways, worth being saved.
3. Definite saving
Most Potlatch users may have made the experience that former work suddenly has disappeared and no history point is available for restore. Nearly all the time there is running a clock, telling “saving data”. I cannot imagine what huge amount of data this thing always is going to save. Especially since a new very quick database seems to be in use. Often I experience that it has saved nothing. And often it also tells me that is has performed an error and that I shall tell someone what crime I have done.
Request: A button to explicitly save a current state and create a history point. After successful save a feedback like: Sir, your precious work has been safely saved for further access, your obedient servant Potlatch.
4. Invisible interconnections
How often have I verified, that ways I tried to connect to each other actually werenÂ’t connected. Or, that ways unintentionally were connected to other objects like rivers ore railways. Unfortunaly, Potlatch offers no visible proof of existing interconnections. Sure, you see, whether there exists a point where the objects touch each other, but the point doesnÂ’t tell anything about real connection. The only reliable proof is, to move a way and to look, whether a suspicious object also moves
Request: Potlatch must make interconnections visible. E.g.: when highlighting a way, display connected points in blue colour.