House number

I understand everyone write in English, so I will too.

a newbie question:
Is there a plan to mark house number in Haifa and Krayot areas ?
is it phase 2 after general street map ?
or it depend on the person who map the streets in that area ?

another thing with the house numbers,
I tried a street I use to leave in.
Ramat gan Hazeitim.
I saw a range on the map (OSM site), but when you try to put a middle number in the search, you get only the street. you get the house only if you write the start/end of the range.
is it defined wrong, or it should be like this ?
At the same street, in “navigator free” I can not get most of the house numbers, only 1,2,18,19 and 20,21,27,28 nothing else.
I saw last update of that street by yrtimiD, 7 month ago.
Please check if it should behave like this with range ?

The problem is that someone doing a wonderful job, but when you need to use it, there is no house :frowning:

Anat

  1. There is no plan - it depends on who is in the area and what they are able to do.

  2. About Ramat Gan Hazeitim - if you search for number 11, the map will zoom to the correct location, however number 1 will be highlighted. The highlighting looks like a bug (or feature?) in the web site, not in the data for Israel.

  3. I also searched for Hazeitim 12 and didn’t find it at all. Looking at the data, I found an error - the range was marked as “addr:interpolation=odd” on both sides of the street. I fixed this, and now it finds even-numbered addresses correctly on this street. If you find any other streets with broken addresses, please tell us so we can look into them.

Hi eric

The number I search, and found the bug at first place, is 3.

Now, after you wrote, I tried all the numbers, just for the game.

all other houses in range give:
בית 24, הזיתים, תל בנימין, רמת גן, מחוז תל אביב, 67448, ישראל
each one with its house numbered searched.

houses 3,23 give:
מגורים הזיתים, תל בנימין, רמת גן, מחוז תל אביב, 67448, ישראל
like houses not in the ranges. but they are in the range and supposed to appear as houses.

I used:
http://www.openstreetmap.org/search?query=ISRAEL%20RAMAT%20GAN%20HAZEITIM%2024#map=18/32.08242/34.81995

This bug can be anywhere ! I just extendedly found, cause I used to live there :slight_smile:
are there rules for entering numbers correctly ?

Hi
I searched for a house in Gordon 25 Tel aviv, and it works,

http://www.openstreetmap.org/node/2079022047

Maybe there is some problem with Hebrew ?
What about Relation:associatedStreet ?
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relation:associatedStreet

dror

your logic is strange.

the fact the you found a house in gordon tel aviv,
does not mean there is no problem in hazeitim ramat gan.

if somewhere is ok, does not mean there is no mistake in another place.

The problem is still there.
houses 3,23 give:
מגורים הזיתים, תל בנימין, רמת גן, מחוז תל אביב, 67448, ישראל
like houses not in the ranges. but they are in the range and supposed to appear as houses.

I don’t have solution.
Maybe an expert will do the same test. on the regular osm site.

I also notice that the lines of numbers are not above all the buildings in the street.
number 1 is above 3, number 19 is above 15,17, number 27 is above 25, and 28 not in the end. all are end points.

so please, someone that is expert:

  1. check the problem with 3 and 23
  2. fix the places of the lines. I still don’t know how to.
  3. pay attention when you mark numbers in other street, that you are above all the buildings in the street.

The is some problem with
הזיתים 3, רמת גן
This address specifically doesn’t show up in Nominatim search. Same with Hazeitim 23.
But all other addresses that I checked do appear.
I don’t know how to explain this. Does anyone have an idea?